When a workplace complaint concerns a CEO or senior manager, first establish who has authority to act without an unmanaged conflict. The usual reporting line may be unsuitable if the respondent controls HR, approves its budget or reports directly to the board.
A clear commissioning arrangement helps protect the investigation from interference and gives participants a workable contact outside that reporting line. Seniority does not establish whether an allegation is true. The process should examine the evidence fairly while the organisation manages immediate risks.
Establish who can commission the work
Check the organisation’s constitution, delegations, relevant policies and governance arrangements. Depending on the entity and the complaint, the appropriate commissioning body might be the board, an authorised committee or another properly authorised person. A chair’s title alone should not be treated as sufficient authority for every step.
Record who may appoint and instruct the investigator, approve expenditure and scope changes, receive the report and make subsequent decisions. If the chair, several directors or the usual legal adviser have relevant involvement, obtain independent governance and legal advice about a workable arrangement before distributing the complaint more widely.
Separate the roles that can otherwise become blurred: receiving a concern, supporting participants, investigating facts, providing legal advice and deciding on employment or governance action. Where one person must perform more than one role, assess and document the implications.
Check for other obligations early
Governance, employment, work health and safety, sector-specific reporting and possible protected-disclosure obligations may overlap. Obtain advice on the applicable regime and any notification requirements, particularly where there are allegations of criminal conduct, corruption or risks to people in care.
A complaint about a senior leader is not automatically a protected whistleblower disclosure. ASIC’s guidance on Corporations Act whistleblower protections explains that eligibility, subject matter and recipient requirements matter. Personal work-related grievances are generally excluded, with important exceptions. Public-sector and other regimes may differ. Assess the position before sharing identities or making assurances about protection.
Manage conflicts and independence
Ask the proposed investigator and those overseeing the process to disclose relevant relationships and previous work. Look beyond direct involvement: an adviser may have drafted the disputed decision, a director may be a likely witness, or an investigator may have a continuing commercial relationship with a participant.
Record the conflict assessment and how any concern will be managed. Where appropriate and authorised, measures may include removing a conflicted person from commissioning decisions, limiting their access to relevant material or appointing someone else. Get governance advice where recusal affects quorum or decision-making authority.
An external investigator needs a clear mandate and a reporting contact who can resolve practical problems without directing the findings. Agree how attempted interference, new conflicts or pressure on witnesses will be escalated. Review the proposed investigator’s experience against the matter’s actual needs.
Fairness remains important at senior level. Legal Aid NSW’s workplace investigation guidance emphasises clear allegations, time to respond and an impartial investigator. The respondent should have a meaningful opportunity to address relevant adverse information; status or pressure for a rapid conclusion should not replace that process.
Preserve records and assess immediate risks
Identify potentially relevant records, their custodians and any automatic deletion settings. Give lawful, appropriately authorised preservation instructions to the people responsible for those systems. Keep a record of what is preserved, by whom and when, without collecting unrelated personal material indiscriminately.
Preserving evidence and accessing it are separate questions. Check privacy, surveillance, employment and information-access requirements before searching accounts, collecting device contents or making recordings. Do not assume a board mandate authorises access to a personal account or every company record.
Assign a separate person to assess current workplace risks and participant support. Possible interim measures might concern reporting lines, meeting arrangements or contact between participants. Consider authority, necessity, fairness and practical impact before making changes. Suspension or changes to duties should receive matter-specific employment advice, rather than follow automatically from the complaint.
Give participants a way to report pressure, exclusion or other adverse treatment during the process. Review the arrangements as circumstances change. Safe Work Australia’s bullying guidance is a useful starting point for understanding the health and safety risks; applicable duties depend on the jurisdiction.
Set reporting and communication boundaries
Before interviews begin, identify who can receive progress reports, evidence and the final report. Keep those access arrangements under review where a recipient becomes involved in the allegations. A general “board circulation” list may be unsuitable for sensitive material.
Explain the process and expected update points to participants without promising absolute confidentiality or a particular outcome. Where protected-disclosure rules may apply, obtain specific advice on identity handling and permitted disclosures. Ordinary need-to-know practices may not meet every statutory requirement.
Agree who handles staff, stakeholder or media enquiries. Keep any authorised message factual and proportionate. If legal professional privilege is important, seek advice at the outset about the purpose and structure of the engagement; an external investigator or “confidential” label does not create privilege automatically.
When the report arrives, check that it addresses the agreed allegations and explains the evidence, responses, findings and any limitations. Send genuine gaps back for clarification. Do not rewrite findings to achieve a preferred employment outcome. The authorised decision-maker should separately consider what action is appropriate and what further process is required.
A hypothetical board scenario
This example is illustrative and is not a Synergy case study. A complaint alleges repeated demeaning conduct by a CEO. HR reports to the CEO, and the chair attended one disputed meeting.
The board first obtains advice on commissioning authority and the chair’s potential witness role. An appropriately authorised, unconflicted oversight arrangement is established. It agrees a defined investigation scope, appoints a suitable investigator and arranges a participant-support contact outside the CEO’s reporting line.
Relevant meeting records and messages are preserved lawfully. The investigator tests the allegations and responses, while the designated oversight contact monitors practical risks and reports of interference. The final findings go to authorised recipients, who consider subsequent decisions through a separate process. Neither appointment nor interim arrangements presume the result.
Board commissioning checklist
- Confirm authority, delegations and any quorum implications
- Assess protected-disclosure, reporting and other legal obligations
- Document conflicts and the arrangements for managing them
- Define allegations, relevant period, policies and scope-change approval
- Name the investigator, oversight contact and later decision-maker
- Authorise proportionate record preservation and lawful access
- Assign participant support and review interim measures
- Agree report recipients, identity safeguards and communications
- Set realistic milestones, budget updates and escalation arrangements
- Keep findings separate from subsequent employment or governance decisions
General information for Australian boards and employers. This checklist is not a determination of your legal authority or obligations. Obtain matter-specific governance, employment, privacy and protected-disclosure advice.

