CLEAR CONCERNS. A FAIR HEARING. INFORMED DECISIONS.

Disciplinary action & procedural fairness

Give your next workplace decision a fair, informed foundation.

Synergy helps employers and HR teams investigate workplace concerns, assess the evidence and document clear findings before disciplinary decisions are made.

Discuss your matter

Free initial consultation   ·   1300 664 341

BEFORE YOU DECIDE

A fair process starts with an open mind.

01   Explain the concerns clearly.

02   Give a genuine opportunity to respond.

03   Consider the evidence before the outcome.

UNDERSTANDING PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS

The process matters as well as the outcome.

Procedural fairness in the workplace means giving a person a fair opportunity to understand and respond to concerns that may affect them, with their response genuinely considered by an impartial decision-maker. It is often associated with natural justice.

For employers, this means approaching allegations with an open mind, making reasonable enquiries and keeping a clear record of the evidence and reasons. An investigation establishes findings; the employer then considers any appropriate management or disciplinary action.

The Fair Work Commission identifies an opportunity to respond before dismissal as a relevant consideration in unfair dismissal matters. See its guidance on the opportunity to respond.

A PRACTICAL FRAMEWORK FOR EMPLOYERS

Six steps towards a fairer process

Adapt the process to the circumstances, relevant policies and applicable employment obligations.

01

Clarify the concerns

Identify the specific conduct or performance issues, relevant policies and questions that need to be resolved. Check for conflicts of interest and agree who will investigate and who will decide.

02

Explain the allegations

Provide enough detail for the employee to understand the concerns and respond meaningfully. Allow reasonable preparation time, taking the complexity of the matter into account.

03

Hear the response

Give the employee a genuine opportunity to explain their account and identify relevant documents or witnesses. Consider support arrangements and any reasonable adjustments needed to participate.

04

Test the evidence

Make reasonable enquiries, examine relevant records and assess competing accounts fairly. Put significant new adverse material to the employee where needed so they can respond.

05

Consider all the information

Assess the response and relevant circumstances before reaching findings. Keep the outcome open throughout the process and distinguish established facts from assumptions.

06

Record and communicate

Document the findings and reasons clearly. The employer considers the appropriate next steps, applicable obligations and how the outcome will be communicated to those involved.

SUPPORT AT THE RIGHT STAGE

How Synergy can help

Whether you need an independent investigator or support for your internal team, we can discuss a scope suited to the matter.

Talk through your next step

Independent workplace investigations

Gather and assess evidence, hear competing accounts and provide reasoned findings. Explore our serious misconduct investigations and workplace bullying investigations.

Support for internal investigators

Get practical assistance with scope, evidence, procedural fairness and report review through our internal investigation support service.

Clear findings for informed decisions

Understand what the evidence supports and why. Our investigation role remains distinct from the employer’s responsibility for management and disciplinary decisions.

Common process pitfalls

  • Deciding the outcome before hearing the employee.
  • Using vague allegations that are difficult to answer.
  • Overlooking relevant evidence or alternative explanations.
  • Failing to keep a clear record of the response and reasons.
  • Confusing an allegation with an established finding.

Handle support-person requests carefully

In unfair dismissal matters, the Fair Work Commission considers whether an employer unreasonably refused a requested support person at discussions relating to dismissal. That provision does not itself create a positive obligation to offer one.

Check applicable policies and obligations, and make participation arrangements clear. Read the Commission’s support-person guidance.

COMMON QUESTIONS

Before taking the next step

How much time should an employee have to respond?

There is no single timeframe suited to every matter. Consider the detail and complexity of the allegations, access to relevant information and the employee’s ability to prepare a meaningful response.

When is an external investigator useful?

External assistance can be useful where allegations are serious or complex, senior staff are involved, internal relationships create a conflict, or your team needs additional capacity and experience.

Does an investigation finding determine disciplinary action?

No. Findings address the allegations and evidence. The employer separately considers the appropriate response, including relevant circumstances, policies and employment obligations. Obtain legal advice where needed on a proposed disciplinary outcome.

Read our guide to procedural fairness in workplace investigations →

TAKE A CONSIDERED NEXT STEP

Need clarity before taking disciplinary action?

Talk with Synergy about the concern, your current process and the investigation support your organisation needs.